---
title: The Operating Risk Model Running Your Plant
description: Plant reliability decisions often hide inside inventory buffers and planning workarounds. Learn how they form an operating risk model—and what it costs.
image: https://www.redsynth.ai/hubfs/image_6.png
---

[Skip to article](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/the-operating-risk-model-running-your-plant#article-content)

[![RedSynth](https://www.redsynth.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/RS-LOGO-RGB_HORIZONTAL-1.png?width=1775&height=402&name=RS-LOGO-RGB_HORIZONTAL-1.png)](https://www.redsynth.ai/)

[Services](https://www.redsynth.ai/#services) [About](https://www.redsynth.ai/about-redsynth) [Insights](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights) [Contact us](https://www.redsynth.ai/#contact)

[← All insights](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights)

supply chain

# The Operating Risk Model Running Your Plant

How informal buffers, conservative assumptions, and operating workarounds become the plan people actually follow.

[Christian Hubbs](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/author/christian-hubbs) RedSynth Insights

Ideas for turning industrial complexity into better decisions.

Share [Email](mailto:?subject=RedSynth%20Insight&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.redsynth.ai%2Finsights%2Fthe-operating-risk-model-running-your-plant) [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.redsynth.ai%2Finsights%2Fthe-operating-risk-model-running-your-plant)

![](https://www.redsynth.ai/hubfs/image_6.png)

#### How informal buffers, conservative assumptions, and operating workarounds become the plan people actually follow.

 

“I know we won’t produce exactly what we plan, so I build in a fudge factor.”

“The supplier says six weeks, but I plan on eight.”

“There are always delays, so I load our top customers early in the month.”

“The stated yield is 92%, but I never plan above 88%.”

Each of these rules is a good-faith attempt for people to manage an uncertain future. And every company is full of these types of rules or heuristics: inventory buffers, loading schedules that prioritize certain accounts, extra material added/removed from production targets, inventory that’s held off to the side for particular customers.

While each fudge factor may be rational on its own, they form a shadow risk model inside the business. Each part is managed in isolation and sometimes in direct tension with other functions or goals.

Nobody designed it and nobody has visibility into it. But it runs the business as much (or more) than the official plan.

## **The hidden cost of a shadow risk model**

These informal protections come with a cost.

A plant’s yield assumption may already be conservative, while the planner adds another production buffer and sales pulls orders forward. This protects against the same risk with three, hidden layers.

At the same time, a key lead-time estimate may be taken at face value, even though it’s consistently wrong.

Because the assumptions and protections are scattered across spreadsheets, conversations, and personal experience, leadership cannot easily answer:

- What risks are we protecting against?
- How much are we paying for that protection?
- Where are we protected twice (or more)?
- Where are we still exposed?
- Which customer, product, or operating condition justifies a larger buffer?
- When should the decision change?

The result is often a strange combination of excess inventory, poor service, unstable schedules, expediting costs, and recurring firefighting. The problem is not that people failed to account for uncertainty. It is that the organization accounted for it implicitly and inconsistently.

## **The consensus plan creates agreement, not certainty**

Monthly S&OP processes are designed to create consensus within the business. Finance, supply chain, manufacturing, and the commercial teams come together to chart out a plan and reach agreement. Despite the consensus, no plan runs as smoothly as expected.

In fact, that’s precisely why we get so many “fudge factors” that gum up operations. Everyone knows the plan will be wrong one way or another. So, these buffers and hidden rules take effect to protect their area of responsibility. Thus, we wind up with two plans: the official plan and the shadow plan people actually implement.

## Three Ways to Account for Uncertainty

It’s a truism in forecasting that the forecast is always wrong. It’s not a matter of getting the precise number, but it’s about getting the range correct so you can plan accordingly and know where those decision points are.

Consider a simple example with a naive production and inventory plan (no uncertainty) vs. one which explicitly accounts for it and a plan made while operating a shadow risk model.

The team forecasts 100,000 tons of demand and, on average, our plant produces 100,000 tons/month. Ahead of the month, we have the decision to produce additional inventory, or not, and incur the holding cost of $20/ton. Let’s also stipulate there’s a penalty of $150/ton for missing an order and we make $50/ton in netback on every sale.

The team gathers together, looks at the average production number and decides we don’t need to build any additional inventory.

This base plan means, at the end of the month there’s no net change in inventory, we expect to be in the same position we’re in now, plus some extra cash in our pockets to the tune of $5,000,000. Now we have our financial target and everyone is committed to the plan.

In reality, nobody expects the plan to be hit on the nose. Production never works out so nicely. So, the sales team massages numbers to hold an extra 15,000 tons for key accounts. The plant knows it needs to hit its numbers too, so they build another 10,000 tons of extra inventory leading up to the month. Now, we’re in a situation where the official plan wants to keep inventory flat, but two separate functions are trying to protect the plan and have pushed inventory up by 25,000 tons.

They all have reason to do this. The plant isn’t perfectly reliable. Let’s say that, based on its history, there are three likely scenarios in front of us:1

- A 25% chance of only producing 85,000 tons (15,000 ton shortfall)
- A 50% chance of producing our 100,000 ton target
- A 25% chance we can produce 115,000 tons (15,000 ton excess)

### Running the official plan

On one hand, we have our official plan. If the 50% case occurs, then everything’s fine and we hit our target. However, if production falls short, then we’re out $3,000,000 versus the financial plan. If everything goes perfectly in the plant, then we have excess inventory and wind up paying $300,000 in excess holding costs.

![](https://www.redsynth.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/undefined-2.png?width=988&height=451&name=undefined-2.png)

Our consensus plan based on our average production looked like a $5,000,000 expected profit, but it was hiding the asymmetric costs. When those are taken into account, our plan now expects to produce $4,175,000, which is 16.5% lower than the naive plan estimated. Quite a shock for finance!

### Running the shadow plan

The shadow plan, on the other hand, increases our carrying cost beyond what management approved, but protects against the downside effectively.

![](https://www.redsynth.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/undefined-3.png?width=988&height=451&name=undefined-3.png)

These types of shadow plans are closer to how most organizations actually operate. They provide extra slack and resources in the system to keep things moving forward. This slack can accumulate over time and leads to slow moving inventory initiatives and other cost containment projects on a regular basis.

Now, let’s ask, “what happens when you de-average your production plan and move uncertainty into the decision?”

### Running the De-Averaged Plan

When we explicitly account for our reliability under the three scenarios and assumed costs, the optimal decision is to build an additional 15,000 tons of inventory. This extra inventory is used as a buffer against the worst case scenario.

![](https://www.redsynth.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/undefined-4.png?width=988&height=451&name=undefined-4.png)

 

This doesn’t come without a cost, of course. 75% of the time, you’re paying an extra $300k of inventory holding costs to maintain this, but it protects against the 25% of cases where production drops off and you lose $3MM in penalties and lost sales vs the plan. With this new inventory, you’ve added $525,000 in expected value to your plan, and $300,000 in expected value over your shadow plan, increasing it to $4.70MM vs. $4.175MM.

Obviously, this is a simplified example: we have a single product, the sales forecast was exact, there was no cost for producing additional inventory (just holding it), and so on. But the fact that the decision shifts in this simplified situation is illustrative of the challenges that teams face who plan based on average assumptions.

## **A better role for S&OP**

The goal should not be to ban the fudge factors (good luck) or abandon the consensus plan. It should be to pull the fudge factors out of the shadows by making them explicit and stop treating the consensus as certainty.

A stronger S&OP process can align around:

- the decisions that must be made now;
- the uncertainty that materially affects those decisions;
- the conditions under which the plan should change;
- the flexibility worth preserving; and
- the economic cost of protection versus exposure.

The future will still surprise us.

But the response no longer has to depend on a hundred invisible rules and the people who happen to remember them.

The organization can plan for being wrong on purpose.

---

1\. Readers may recognize this as a version of the *newsvendor problem*. In this case, we have discrete, stochastic yields and known demand. For a close match to the formulation here, see [Keren, 2009](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0305048308000881). For a general survey, I recommend [Yano *et al.*, 1995](https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/abs/10.1287/opre.43.2.311), and for the canonical treatment of the classical problem, see [Arrow *et al*., 1951](https://www.jstor.org/stable/1906813).

 

Written by

[Christian Hubbs](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/author/christian-hubbs)

[supply chain](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/supply-chain)[decision science](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/decision-science)[industrial decision science](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/industrial-decision-science)[inventory](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/inventory)[inventory management](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/inventory-management)[s&op](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/sop)[enterprise risk](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/enterprise-risk)[uncertainty](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/tag/uncertainty)

RedSynth Insights

Practical thinking at the intersection of AI, optimization, and industrial decision-making.

[Explore every insight →](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights)

Keep reading

## More from RedSynth

[View all insights →](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights)

### [Inventory, Inventory Everywhere It’s the last few weeks of the quarter and the regular call goes out: cut inventory. Whatever it takes, we have to hit t… Read article →](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/inventory-inventory-everywhere)

### [How to Find the Margin Decisions Your Dashboard Can’t Make We were 90 minutes in and just wrapped up a 110 slide PowerPoint presentation to a global business VP at a major petroch… Read article →](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/how-to-find-the-margin-decisions-your-dashboard-cant-make)

### [Your Company is Long on Data but Short on Decisions Your Company Is Long on Data but Short on Decisions My jaw nearly hit the floor when a leader at a major oil and gas com… Read article →](https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/your-company-is-long-on-data-but-short-on-decisions)

## Turn insight into operating advantage.

Talk with RedSynth about the decisions creating friction in your business.

[Start a conversation →](https://www.redsynth.ai/#contact)

[![RedSynth](https://www.redsynth.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/RS-LOGO-RGB_HORIZONTAL-1.png?width=1775&height=402&name=RS-LOGO-RGB_HORIZONTAL-1.png)](https://www.redsynth.ai/)

Copyright © 2026

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Christian Hubbs",
    "url" : "https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/author/christian-hubbs"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-04T14:54:23.874Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-03T23:55:19.000Z",
  "headline" : "The Operating Risk Model Running Your Plant",
  "image" : [ "https://www.redsynth.ai/hubfs/image_6.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.redsynth.ai/insights/the-operating-risk-model-running-your-plant",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.redsynth.ai/hubfs/RS-LOGO-RGB_HORIZONTAL-1.png"
    }
  }
}
```